12 Days of Cookies Day 3: Bridgeman’s Butter Brittle Ice Cream Sandwich Cookies

Elizabeth has not stopped raving about this cookie ever since she tasted it – three ingredients and an out-of-this-world wow factor. Baking Instructor Nancy Burgeson was issued a special challenge this year: use Bridgeman’s Ice Cream as an ingredient in a cookie recipe. Nancy knocked it out of the park when she created Bridgeman’s Butter Brittle Ice Cream Sandwich Cookies using melted ice cream as an ingredient in the cookies and the frosting.

Nancy uses Bridgeman’s Butter Brittle Ice Cream in her recipes and says it’s perfect as an ice cream sandwich filling as well!

Bridgeman’s Ice Cream has been stirring up sweet memories for over 80 years when the original Bridgeman’s Ice Cream Shoppe opened its doors back in 1936. They have 14 different flavors including their newest holiday flavor, Peppermint Krisp.

Click here to find a location to buy Bridgeman’s Ice Cream near you.

Bridgeman’s Butter Brittle Ice Cream Sandwich Cookies

1 cup unsalted butter-softened
1/3 cup Bridgeman’s Butter Brittle Ice Cream-melted (measure ice cream after melted)
2 cups all-purpose flour
Granulated sugar

Cream butter and ice cream until light and somewhat fluffy.
Add in flour and mix to blend well.
If you would like dough tinted for a special holiday add food coloring.
Wrap and refrigerate for 1-2 hours.
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Roll dough out on floured counter. (I use Wondra flour for the best results for rolling out cookies)
Cut with a shaped cutter i.e. round, square, rectangle, etc.
Roll to a thickness of 1/8 to 1/4 inch.
Using parchment paper fit to your cookie sheet, cover sheet lightly with granulated sugar. Transfer cookies from counter to cookie sheet coating cookies on both sides with the granulated sugar.
Using the tines of a fork prick cookies in several places on cookie in a pattern of your choosing.
Bake 7-9 minutes or until lightly browned at edges-do not overbake.

Cookies can be filled with softened Bridgeman’s Butter Brittle Ice Cream just prior to serving for a yummy ice cream sandwich or filled with the Butter Brittle frosting recipe below:

Bridgeman’s Butter Brittle Frosting

3/4 cup unsalted butter-softened
4 cups powdered sugar
1 tsp vanilla
1/4 cup softened Butter Brittle Ice Cream

Blend together until combined. Beat at medium speed of mixer until light and fluffy.
Spread between 2 cookies for a tasty filling.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email